Audiophilia: The Tragically Hip - Phamtom Power - Christopher Tocher's review: "enough razor sharp vocals and earthy melodies to satisfy all but the most discerning lovers of good rock." www.audiophilia.com/software/ct4.htm
Canoe.ca: The Tragically Hip - Phamtom Power - Dirk Soeterik's review: "a balanced menu of up-tempo, rocking songs and mellow ballads that are perfect for sundown at the cottage." www.canoe.ca/JamAlbumsT/tragicallyhip_phantom2.html
Imprint: The Tragically Hip - Phamtom Power - John Lofranco's review: "The Hip continue to improve and change, while still maintaining the best elements of their previous work." imprint.uwaterloo.ca/issues/071798/6Arts/New_Revolutions/newrevs04.shtml
Pitchfork: The Tragically Hip - Phamtom Power - Samir Khan's review: "if you like literate, well-thought-out, straight-up rock, you could do a whole lot worse than this horribly-named band." www.pitchforkmedia.com/record-reviews/t/tragically-hip/phantom-power.shtml
Rocknworld.com : The Tragically Hip - Phamtom Power - Stephen Jordan's review: "The songs have a deep meaning and there are no fillers; every song is worth listening to." www.rocknworld.com/reviews/fans/th.shtml